HSSE Online

Past Issues

   Back
08 May 2023

Volume 10 Issue 1 2021

HSSE Online Editorial

This year marks the twentieth anniversary of the introduction of Social Studies (SS) in Singapore secondary schools. Originally conceived as part of a push for National Education, SS has since expanded in ambit to address contemporary issues and to equip students with the tools of social inquiry. By bringing into conversation the voices of scholars and practitioners, this special issue of HSSE Online captures the vitality of Singapore’s present-day SS education landscape.

The first article by Aloysius Foo stands in the tradition of the sociology of education. Using the case study of a heartland Junior College, Foo challenges our assumptions about “neighbourhood schools” by highlighting the density of cultural, symbolic, and emotional capital in nonelite environments. In so doing, Foo calls on readers to focus on the strengths rather than the deficits of their respective school communities. The consummate researcher-practitioner, Foo reminds us that classrooms are, themselves, the sites of complex social phenomena, which invite self-reflexivity from SS educators.

The next two articles focus on aspects of the secondary SS curriculum, which since 2016 has been organised around the principles of Inquiry-Based Learning (IBL). Recognising the central but under-explored role of framing questions as part of IBL, Peidong Yang and Jun Yan Chua propose a taxonomy of SS inquiry questions. Collectively, the “Politician’s Question”, the “Social Scientist’s Question”, and the “Social Worker’s Question” reflect a range of approaches toward the disciplinarity of SS. Moving beyond traditional debates about the appropriate aims of SS education, Yang and Chua provide teachers and students with a heuristic for thinking about different starting points for social inquiry.

Drawing on findings from the Core Research Programme—a large-scale, cross-sectional, baseline investigation of pedagogical practices in Singapore classrooms— Fatema Anis Hussain offers insights into the reality of inquiry learning enactment in the present-day secondary SS classroom. Examining both qualitative and quantitative data, Hussain captures the complexities, challenges, and considerations in Singapore SS teachers’ pragmatic approach to inquiry learning.

Diversity and inclusion have emerged as focal issues in Singapore society of late, with significant implications for SS education. Two articles engage with these questions in the context of primary SS. Wang Yao Chang Melvin examines the effectiveness of graphic organisers in improving reading comprehension of SS informational texts in upper primary students with High Functioning Autism. His iterative, evidence-based approach reflects the deep commitment of educators to supporting students with Special Educational Needs, and to making SS accessible for all.

Using the framework of Multicultural Education, Adele Seah Pei Jia unpacks the treatment of diversity in the revised 2020 Primary Social Studies syllabus. Seah’s project grew out of NTU’s Undergraduate Research Experience on Campus (URECA) programme, which aims to promote a culture of inquiry in the most academically able undergraduate students. In the light of ongoing public debates about multiculturalism, which some commentators have attributed to generational change, Seah’s perspective on the issue as a future SS educator is especially valuable.

The issue concludes with a review essay by Pang Wei Han, who surveys three recent works in Singapore Studies, and discusses how teachers might apply their findings as dynamic content in the secondary SS curriculum. Although SS educators unanimously recognise the importance of engaging with current issues in their classrooms, the competing demands placed on teachers can make it challenging to keep up with the rich array of social research emerging from the local research ecosystem. Both editors wished they read more extensively, and Pang has done us all a service by distilling insights from the frontiers of scholarship on Singapore.  

When SS was first implemented at the Upper Secondary level in 2001, it was not without its skeptics. Twenty years on, in an increasingly volatile and complex environment, the relevance and necessity of SS is no longer in question. The range of perspectives in this issue reflect the profound belief that SS scholars and practitioners share about the importance of the subject. As they reimagine the futures of SS, the work in this volume also pays tribute to a generation of SS educators in Singapore.

Peidong and Jun Yan

Singapore

November 2021

“Neighbourhood Schools” and Their Positive Forms of Capital in Singapore

Author/s:

Aloysius Foo (National Institute of Education (Singapore)) Keywords Social Studies Junior College Secondary School Social Studies social studies education Singapore teacher professional learning   While the term “neighbourhood school” is popularly used in Singaporean parlance as well as by academics to describe a typical, government-run school, it has not been subjected to close scrutiny. Using Pierre […]

Aloysius Foo (National Institute of Education (Singapore))

Keywords
Social Studies
Junior College
Secondary School
Social Studies
social studies education
Singapore
teacher professional learning

 

While the term “neighbourhood school” is popularly used in Singaporean parlance as well as by academics to describe a typical, government-run school, it has not been subjected to close scrutiny. Using Pierre Bourdieu’s theory of different forms of capital and capital conversion, this article situates neighbourhood schools within Singapore’s stratified educational landscape.

Although these schools lack the privileges and recognition of elite schools, their students possess and mobilise their own forms of cultural, symbolic and emotional capital which empower them. This article is relevant for socially-conscious educators, Social Studies teachers and curriculum specialists who are keen to explore the notion of “diversity” through education and social class.

Download Full Article

“This Is What Social Studies Can Look Like”: Adapting Recent Work in Singapore Studies for The SS Classroom

Author/s:

Pang Wei Han(Raffles Institution (Singapore)) Keywords Social Studies Secondary School Social Studies social studies education Singapore teacher professional learning According to the Upper Secondary (Express/Normal Academic) Social Studies Teaching and Learning Guide, dynamic content “refers to knowledge needed for students to amplify and deepen their understanding of the core content” and “can take the form […]

Pang Wei Han(Raffles Institution (Singapore))
Keywords
Social Studies
Secondary School
Social Studies
social studies education
Singapore
teacher professional learning

According to the Upper Secondary (Express/Normal Academic) Social Studies Teaching and Learning Guide, dynamic content “refers to knowledge needed for students to amplify and deepen their understanding of the core content” and “can take the form of examples found in the Coursebook, or can be examples derived from discussions and explorations students undertake in school and outside of school” (Ministry of Education, 2015, p. 12). This review article was conceptualised with the intention of supporting Social Studies educators by supplementing their toolkit of dynamic content and sources. In addition to presenting an overview of three recently-published texts in the field of Singapore Studies, I will draw linkages with key concepts in the SS curriculum and suggest potential pedagogical approaches to leveraging these texts in the classroom. In keeping with the renewed emphasis on Character and Citizenship Education (CCE), I also remark on how the texts can tie in with various CCE strands, including Values-in-Action, Education and Career Guidance, and discussion of contemporary issues.

Download Full Article

Multicultural Education: An Analysis of the 2020 Primary Social Studies Curriculum

Author/s:

Adele Seah Pei Jia (National Institute of Education (Singapore)) Keywords Primary Social Studies Primary School Multicultural Education (ME) teaches learners to overcome differences in areas like culture, ethnicity, and social class. By equipping learners with the cultural knowledge, skills and dispositions to embrace diversity, ME enables individuals to navigate an increasingly complex world. Given the […]

Adele Seah Pei Jia (National Institute of Education (Singapore))

Keywords
Primary Social Studies
Primary School

Multicultural Education (ME) teaches learners to overcome differences in areas like culture, ethnicity, and social class. By equipping learners with the cultural knowledge, skills and dispositions to embrace diversity, ME enables individuals to navigate an increasingly complex world. Given the limited local research on ME, this paper examines how elements of ME have been incorporated into the 2020 Primary Social Studies (PSS) curriculum in Singapore. The study revealed that the PSS curriculum comprises a wide variety of multicultural elements. At lower primary, these elements focus on building personal and cultural knowledge. In contrast, at upper primary, such elements are introduced as mainstream academic knowledge. The study further found that the PSS curriculum adopts a contributions and additive approach to implementing ME. However, Singapore’s unique ideology of multiracialism also influences the PSS curriculum, placing PSS in tension with social action and transformative approaches to ME. The implications of these findings on teaching and learning are discussed.

Download Full Article

Improving Reading Comprehension of Social Studies Informational Text for Upper Primary Students with High Functioning Autism

Author/s:

Wang Yao Chang Melvin (Rosyth School (Singapore) Keywords> Primary Social Studies Primary School Controversial Issues Classroom One of the main barriers to teaching Social Studies to students diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) pertains to their limited ability to read and comprehend written informational text. This study investigated the use of graphic organiser instruction to promote […]

Wang Yao Chang Melvin (Rosyth School (Singapore)

Keywords>
Primary Social Studies
Primary School
Controversial Issues
Classroom

One of the main barriers to teaching Social Studies to students diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) pertains to their limited ability to read and comprehend written informational text. This study investigated the use of graphic organiser instruction to promote improved informational text comprehension for three upper primary students with High Functioning Autism (HFA). Student participants were introduced to the specific vocabulary terms in the graphic organiser in three stages: introduction of the vocabulary word and its definition; deductive teaching of concepts through the use of examples and non-examples; and student practice. Subsequently, all three students were instructed to read adapted passages on Singapore history and complete the modified graphic organisers. The effect of the intervention was then assessed within the context of a multiple-probe design across participants, using quizzes that measured performance through multiple-choice and open-ended test items. Results demonstrated that the intervention improved students’ reading comprehension.

Download Full Article

Related Teaching Materials

Attachment Size
 Appendix A 158 KB

“So What Makes the Prime Minister’s Speech So Reliable?” – Secondary Social Studies Teachers’ Pragmatic Approach To Inquiry

Author/s:

Fatema Anis Hussain (National Institute of Education (Singapore)) Keywords Social Studies Secondary School An inquiry-based approach in the classroom equips students with discipline-based skills, thus facilitating knowledge construction (Kidman & Casinader, 2017). In view of the curricular focus in Singapore on developing students’ critical and reflective thinking skills via inquiry (MOE, 2016a), this article illustrates […]

Fatema Anis Hussain (National Institute of Education (Singapore))

Keywords
Social Studies
Secondary School

An inquiry-based approach in the classroom equips students with discipline-based skills, thus facilitating knowledge construction (Kidman & Casinader, 2017). In view of the curricular focus in Singapore on developing students’ critical and reflective thinking skills via inquiry (MOE, 2016a), this article illustrates teachers’ enactment of inquiry processes in secondary Social Studies lessons, drawing on data from a baseline study. Analysis of teacher interviews and student focus group discussions yields insights into the possibilities and challenges of employing inquiry-based learning. The article spotlights teacher-student interactions in one particular lesson as students ascertain the reliability of the given sources. The analysis reveals teachers’ pragmatic, fit-for-purpose approach to selecting key aspects of inquiry-based learning, which is largely driven by time constraints and concerns about syllabus coverage and students’ assessment outcomes. These findings suggest the need for greater student agency in the inquiry process as well as more opportunities for students’ critical and reflective thinking, and domain-specific understandings.

Download Full Article

Related Teaching Materials

Attachment Size
 Appendix A 154 KB
 Appendix B 132 KB

A Politician, A Social Scientist, and A Social Worker Walk Into A Bar: Towards A Taxonomy Of Social Studies Inquiry Questions

Author/s:
,

Peidong Yang (National Institute of Education (Singapore)) Jun Yan Chua (Dunearn Secondary School (Singapore)) Keywords Social Studies Secondary School Social Studies social studies education Singapore teacher professional learning Inquiry-based learning has gained prominence in secondary-school humanities education in Singapore in recent years. In Social Studies (SS), the loci of inquiry learning are “Issue Investigation” as […]

Peidong Yang (National Institute of Education (Singapore))
Jun Yan Chua (Dunearn Secondary School (Singapore))
Keywords
Social Studies
Secondary School
Social Studies
social studies education
Singapore
teacher professional learning

Inquiry-based learning has gained prominence in secondary-school humanities education in Singapore in recent years. In Social Studies (SS), the loci of inquiry learning are “Issue Investigation” as found in the 2016 Express and Normal (Academic) syllabus and “Performance Task” in the 2014/15 Normal (Technical) syllabus, respectively. Due to the relatively short time inquiry has been given explicit emphasis, to date research into this new aspect of SS education remains very limited. This paper focuses on an important yet often neglected step of the SS inquiry process—the development of inquiry questions. To explore how different ways of crafting the SS inquiry question may lead to distinct inquiry approaches and processes, a taxonomy of SS inquiry questions is proposed based on empirical observations. The taxonomy comprises three categories of questions: the “politician’s question”, the “social worker’s question”, and the “social scientist’s question”. The implications and applications of this taxonomy for SS instruction are also discussed with reference to the multi-faceted aims of SS education in Singapore.

Download Full Article

Scroll to Top